Mindprint Toolbox

Search Results

Please wait...

Explore Alternative Meanings in Close Reading

Tags

ELA: Reading ^21st Century Skills MS/HS/College Strategy

Skills

Flexible Thinking Verbal Reasoning

Explore Alternative Meanings in Close Reading

If your student is ready to take their reading to a deeper level

Teach It!

  1. Objective: Help students read text for multiple layers of interpretation.
  2. Instruction: Explain why. Explain how skilled writers make deliberate word choices and how skilled readers pause on words to understand the deeper meaning and nuance behind those choices. When we pause to explore why a writer chose one word or phrase over another we can often gain a better perspective on the author's purpose for writing and the deeper message the author wants to convey.
  3. Practice: Even if you are not teaching a poetry unit, poetry emphasizes the importance of word choice and the multiple ways a single word or phrase can be interpreted. Discuss passages from authors known for using symbolism in their work such as Rand, Melville, Wright, Heller and Updike. Use authors from diverse backgrounds to display how personal experience and context can influence one's interpretation. Have students reflect on how their first interpretation of an author's meaning can change when they carefully consider word choice and evaluate context clues.
  4. Diverse Discussion Groups: Have students freely discuss authors' style and purpose with the primary objective of understanding how people can read the same words but extract very different meanings. When possible include students from different backgrounds to ensure a diversity of opinions and enable students to understand how individual experiences can influence perspectives of what we read.
  5. Ongoing reinforcement: Pose questions that allow for multiple correct responses in your classwork. Allow students time to express different points of view or possibilities for author's meaning. When students express divergent views, pair them up and have them explain their thinking to each other. End lessons with questions left unanswered so students gain comfort with the ambiguity and some might continue to search for clues for understanding.

Why It Works (the Science Of Learning)!

It is critical that students understand that there are often many ways to consider an issue or solve a problem, and that not all problems have a right or wrong answer. This is important well beyond academic learning. Many social, political and ethical issues are fraught with gray areas that students will need to consider to fully understand the complexity of a situation. Students, regardless of reasoning ability, might be more or less comfortable with ambiguity. Providing students with opportunities to explore authors' meaning will develop critical thinking skills that go beyond reading literature.